In the wake of filing a lawsuit against Garmin over Segments and Heatmaps, Strava has now taken to Reddit to explain its side of the story. On October 2, Chief Product Officer Matt Salazar posted in r/Strava, outlining why Strava is fighting Garmin’s new API guidelines.

Setting the record straight about Garmin
by u/strava-team in Strava

Strava’s Chief Product Officer Matt Salazar posted this explanation in r/Strava

Strava’s Position

According to Salazar, Garmin’s new developer guidelines, announced July 1, require the Garmin logo to appear on every activity screen, graph, image, and sharing card. Strava was given until November 1 to comply, or risk being cut off from Garmin’s API.

Strava argues it refused to comply for two main reasons:

  • They consider it blatant advertising that degrades user experience.
  • They believe activity data is the user’s own and should not be tied to forced branding.
“We already provide attribution for every data partner, but Garmin wants to use Strava and every other partner as an advertising platform… We consider this to be YOUR data. If you recorded an activity on your watch, we think that is your data.” – Matt Salazar, Strava CPO

Community Reaction

The response from users in the thread was overwhelmingly critical of Strava’s stance. Many pointed out what they saw as hypocrisy, given Strava’s own history of restricting API use by third parties in 2024:

  • “Pot calling the kettle black” – multiple users noted Strava itself weaponized its API last year by banning developers from using Strava data, forcing deletions of millions of activities.
  • “I’ll choose Garmin” – many paying Strava subscribers said they would cancel their memberships if Garmin syncing was cut off, emphasizing that Garmin is the reason they use Strava at all.
  • Advertising complaints – commenters argued that Strava already floods the app with challenges and promotions that are far more intrusive than a small Garmin logo.
  • PR backlash – several users mocked Strava’s decision to frame the issue as protecting users, calling the post one of the most “tone-deaf” corporate communications they had seen.
“Hasn’t Strava weaponized their API against others already? Isn’t it MY data?” – u/rcuadro
“As a premium (paid) Strava member I want to be clear that Strava’s only of use to me if it works with Garmin. The moment Garmin no longer syncs is the last time I open Strava.” – u/Bogmanbob
“Literally just cite Garmin like you cite Google Earth. This is such an own goal by Strava.” – u/gray19

Why It Matters

This Reddit post comes as Strava is pursuing a separate lawsuit against Garmin in federal court. That legal case focuses on Segments and Heatmaps patents, while this Reddit controversy is about API branding rules. In many ways Strava is fighting fire with fire by filing a lawsuit on an issue unrelated to their data attribution complaint.

With Garmin devices representing one of the largest sources of uploads to Strava, the stakes are extremely high: losing access could undermine Strava’s core value to its 150 million athletes.

Looking Ahead

Strava says it continues to negotiate with Garmin but has refused to accept what it sees as unfair terms. For now, activities continue to sync, but the November 1 deadline looms. The Reddit backlash highlights how risky this battle is for Strava, especially with an IPO on the horizon.

0
comments · 0 threads

Add your watch so others know which model you're on.

Also get firmware emails for your watch.

    No comments yet. Start the conversation.